James Toney Brings the Mix into Mixed Martial Arts
- August 28th, 2010
- Write comment
By: Daniel Luu
Dana White is not hiding what he thinks of Saturday’s night co-main event. The so-called freak show fight between boxing star James Toney and UFC legend Randy Couture is touted as a boxing versus MMA matchup. But it isn’t the first time a boxer collided with a grappler. It’s a fight thats been happening for over a 100 years.
Some of the earliest publicized bouts between a boxer and a grappler were the exhibition matches between John L .Sullivan and William Muldoon back in the late 19th century. In 1901, wrestler Gus Ruhlin was able to defeat boxing heavyweight champion Bob Fitzsimmons in a mixed bout. In 1963, fame grappler Gene LeBell choked out top ranked light heavyweight Milo Savage. Even in the UFC’s short history, Art Jimmerson tapped out to Royce Gracie at UFC 1 and even more recently Tim Sylvia was knocked out by Ray Mercer in the first seven seconds back in 2009.
And while most believe that the UFC brass is bringing in Toney to just solely lose, the UFC can use more elite fighters from traditional martial art backgrounds. There’s a reason why Lyoto Machida karate techniques became so popular in the Octagon: it went back to the premise of style versus style. The same can be said for Cung Le’s flashy kicks and takedowns. These fighters garner a lot of fanfare because they aren’t training MMA. They’re traditional martial artists who are good at other styles as well.
The whole principal of MMA is to see what fighting style can thrive inside an environment that allows for grappling, submissions, and striking. We’ve seen elite wrestlers and elite Brazilian Jiu Jitsu practitioners enter the world of MMA, but rarely have we seen any elite boxer. With so many MMA fighters being good at everything and not great at anything, it’s refreshing to see an elite boxer in the midst trying to prove what elite boxing can offer to MMA.
Boxing has seen better days. If Randy Couture wins this Saturday night, it will be a symbolic gesture that MMA has surpassed boxing in determining who is the number one fighter in the world. But what makes this bout more significant for longtime fight fans is that finally both boxing and MMA are in the limelight. It’s no longer a boxer versus a small time sport. It’s two legit athletes from two different combat backgrounds determining who can implement their style on the other opponent better.